Categories
BlogPublished October 19, 2026
How Do You Know What You Can Actually Afford When Upgrading to a Bigger Home in Sioux Falls in 2026?
How Much Home Can You REALLY Afford in Sioux Falls
The short answer: run the real net numbers from your current home before you look at a single listing. Most Sioux Falls families upgrading in 2026 are working from an equity figure that is anywhere from $20,000 to $25,000 higher than what they will actually have in hand at closing. Knowing that gap upfront changes everything about how you plan your move.
What Is the Difference Between Your Equity and Your Actual Cash?
Equity is what your home is worth on paper minus what you owe. Cash is what you walk away with after selling. Those two numbers are not the same, and the gap between them is the most common reason Sioux Falls upgrade plans stall.
We use a tool called the REAL NET TEST with every client before they start shopping. It sounds simple, but most families skip it because they assume their equity number is close enough. It usually is not.
Here is how the purchase price, down payment, and rate combine into a monthly payment. Say your starter home is worth $289,900 and you still owe $210,000. On paper, that is $80,000 in equity. But seller costs in South Dakota typically run 9 to 10 percent of your sale price. On a $289,900 home, that is roughly $20,000. South Dakota also requires a tax proration paid to the buyer at closing because property taxes here are paid in arrears, meaning you are currently paying last year's taxes and the buyer needs to be caught up to the closing date. In this example, that proration is approximately $4,000. After those two items alone, your $80,000 becomes about $55,000 in usable cash. A $24,000 difference, and it is completely normal.
The reason this matters for families like yours: if you were budgeting a down payment based on $80,000 and your real number is $55,000, your target price range shifts significantly before you ever make an offer.
Why Does South Dakota's Tax System Affect What You Net at Closing?
This catches a lot of sellers off guard. Because South Dakota collects property taxes in arrears, you are always paying the previous year's bill. When you sell, the buyer is entitled to a credit covering the portion of the current year that you owned the home. That credit comes directly out of your proceeds at closing.
In the example above, that proration runs about $4,000. This is simply how the math works in this state. Knowing about it in advance means it does not blindside you the week of closing.
The breakdown of what makes up that 9 to 10 percent total cost in Sioux Falls: realtor commission averages around 5.84 to 6 percent total, closing costs run roughly 3.27 percent, and smaller items like transfer taxes round it out. These figures are predictable. We know them ahead of time, which means they are plannable.
What Does the Buying Side of This Move Actually Cost?
Families doing a simultaneous sell and buy often fixate on selling costs and forget that the buying side is usually much cleaner. As a buyer, your main out-of-pocket expenses are your down payment, lender closing costs, a home inspection, and moving costs. In Sioux Falls, sellers still commonly cover a significant portion of transaction costs on the buying side, which keeps your cash requirement lower than in many other markets.
We recently worked with a young family who moved back to Sioux Falls to be closer to family. They were selling in Minnesota. We connected with their Minnesota agent early, calculated exactly what they would net from that sale, and then walked through what that number could buy here in Sioux Falls. They started shopping with a real number, not a guess. The process felt manageable because the math was settled before they fell in love with any house.
When you look at the full picture of both transactions together, selling and buying, the combined cost is often more efficient than people expect going in.
How Do You Know If the Monthly Payment Will Actually Feel Okay?
Bank approval and real-life comfort are two different things. The bank looks at your debt ratios and credit. You have to think about what $800 less per month actually means when a kid gets sick, when the furnace needs work, or when you want to take a family trip without the stress of watching every dollar.
If you are going from a $1,600 monthly payment to $2,400, that is $800 less every month for everything else in your life. Before we look at what the bank will approve, we want clients to know what they are genuinely comfortable carrying. Because the goal is to love the house and still feel good about the payment, not to qualify for the most you can get and spend the next ten years feeling squeezed.
The families we work with who feel best about their move afterward are the ones who set their own comfort number first, then let the bank's approval work within it.
How Should You Price Your Current Home if You Need a Specific Net?
Pricing strategy in the current Sioux Falls market is not about listing high and hoping. Right now, the average seller is getting 96.3 percent of asking price. On a $289,900 listing, that realistically means closer to $279,000 at the table. And 43 percent of recent sellers have had to reduce their price at least once, which is the highest reduction rate since 2017.
Homes priced accurately from the start consistently outperform homes that open high and chase the market down with reductions. If you need $55,000 net from your sale to make your upgrade work, the pricing conversation starts there. We work backward from your required net using comparable sales and current market data to find a list price that gives you a real shot at reaching that number, not just a number that looks good on a sign.
What Happens If Something Goes Wrong During the Simultaneous Move?
15.1 percent of contracts are falling through right now, which is the highest fallout rate since 2017. That number is a reason to have a backup plan before you need one.
Three scenarios worth thinking through in advance: your buyer's financing falls through after you are already under contract on your next home, the right home appears before your current home goes under contract, or you receive a strong offer with a timeline that is faster than you expected. Each of those has a workable answer. Temporary housing is one option. Conditional timing in your offer is another. There are financing tools designed specifically for the gap between selling and buying.
When you have thought through those scenarios ahead of time, you make calmer decisions. You are not scrambling to figure out options when you are already under pressure.
Start With the Real Numbers
The families who feel good about their upgrade in 2026 are the ones who ran the REAL NET TEST before they looked at a single home. They knew their actual usable cash, they set a monthly payment they could genuinely live with, they priced their home to hit a specific net target, and they had a plan for the situations that sometimes do not go according to schedule.
If you want to walk through your own numbers, the affordability calculator linked below covers the net sheet math, the monthly payment comfort test, and the backup plan scenarios specific to Sioux Falls.
Watch the full breakdown here : https://youtu.be/BBi8ywT2gaY
Julie Roth
Realtor® | Sioux Falls & Harrisburg Real Estate Expert | Julie Roth Real Estate
or another way
.png)